Jack Grealish, once the vibrant heart of Aston Villa’s attack, has found himself at a crossroads at Manchester City, with his limited role under Pep Guardiola sparking fierce criticism from pundit Jamie O’Hara. The former Tottenham midfielder branded Guardiola a “spoilt brat” for his handling of the £100 million winger, accusing the manager of “ruining” Grealish’s flair and seemingly preparing to “bin” him after a lackluster 2024-25 season. O’Hara’s scathing remarks, voiced on talkSPORT, have ignited a broader debate about Guardiola’s tactical rigidity and its impact on one of England’s most charismatic talents, as Grealish’s future at the Etihad Stadium hangs in the balance.
Grealish, who joined City in 2021 for a British record fee, was a revelation at Villa, where his fearless dribbling and playmaking earned him 18 direct goal involvements in 26 Premier League games during his final season. “He was one of the most exciting players in the league,” O’Hara lamented, reflecting on Grealish’s dynamic style that made him the most fouled player in the Premier League. At City, however, his output has dwindled, with just four goals and two assists in the league since the 2023-24 season. His role has shifted from a free-spirited creator to a disciplined cog in Guardiola’s system, prioritizing possession and safe passing over risk-taking. This transformation culminated in Grealish’s omission from the squad for City’s crucial 2-0 win over Fulham on the final day of the 2024-25 season, a decision that secured Champions League qualification but fueled speculation about his departure.
Guardiola defended his choice, insisting it was purely tactical. “It’s not anything personal, absolutely anything!” he snapped at reporters, emphasizing his long-standing support for Grealish. “I’m the person who fought for him to come to City and to stay this season and the next. I’m the one who said, ‘I want Jack Grealish.’” Yet, he acknowledged Grealish’s need for regular play, stating, “Of course, Jack has to play—that’s the truth. He’s an unbelievable player who needs to play every three days, and it didn’t happen this season or last.” The manager’s comments, paired with his decision to favor younger players like Savinho and Claudio Echeverri, have led critics like O’Hara to argue that Guardiola’s approach has stifled Grealish’s natural game. “If that happened with Declan Rice at Arsenal, Mikel Arteta would get the sack,” O’Hara fumed. “You’ve spent £100 million on Jack Grealish, and you’re binning him. Get more out of him. Figure it out.”
The criticism extends beyond O’Hara. Thierry Henry, analyzing a Manchester derby clip, expressed dismay at Grealish’s cautious play, noting, “That’s not the Jack Grealish I saw at Villa.” Alan Shearer, meanwhile, declared Grealish’s time at City “done” after he was overlooked for a substitute role in the FA Cup final loss to Crystal Palace, where Guardiola opted for 19-year-old debutant Echeverri and Ilkay Gundogan. “For him to bring a young boy on when they’re desperate for a goal rather than Jack Grealish… his time is up,” Shearer said on The Rest Is Football podcast. The snub, coupled with Grealish’s exclusion from England’s Euro 2024 squad and Thomas Tuchel’s latest World Cup qualifier selections, has intensified calls for the 29-year-old to seek a move elsewhere to revive his career.
Grealish’s struggles are set against City’s transitional 2024-25 season, which saw them finish third after a trophy-less campaign, their first in eight years. Guardiola, grappling with an oversized squad of 32 players, admitted, “Selecting from 25 players has been a nightmare. It causes fractions in the locker room.” His preference for explosive wingers like Jeremy Doku and Savinho, who offer pace and directness, has marginalized Grealish, whose 22% of available Premier League minutes this season reflects his fall down the pecking order. “Savinho is in better shape than Jack,” Guardiola said bluntly, pointing to the Brazilian’s superior delivery in the box.
As speculation mounts about a summer transfer—AC Milan, Tottenham, and even a return to Aston Villa have been linked—Grealish remains determined. Former teammate Gabby Agbonlahor praised his work ethic, saying, “I know for a fact he’s been working so hard with fitness coaches, personal trainers. He’s coming back with a vengeance.” For now, Grealish’s immediate focus is the FIFA Club World Cup, though his inclusion in City’s squad remains uncertain. As Guardiola navigates a squad overhaul, with director of football Txiki Begiristain’s departure and Hugo Viana’s arrival, Grealish’s future hinges on whether he can rediscover the spark that once made him a Premier League sensation.
Leave a Reply