Jack Grealish’s loan move to Everton from Manchester City for the 2025-26 season has sparked intrigue, not just for its potential to revive the England star’s career but also for the challenges it poses. Gary Neville, a Manchester United legend turned pundit, has drawn a striking parallel between Grealish’s situation and the frustrations Cristiano Ronaldo faced during his second stint at United. Speaking on the Unfiltered Soccer Podcast with Landon Donovan and Tim Howard, Neville voiced concerns that Grealish, accustomed to the star-studded environment of a treble-winning City side, might struggle to adapt to Everton’s less polished squad. This move, seen as a chance for Grealish to rediscover his spark, could test his patience and leadership in ways that echo Ronaldo’s turbulent return to Old Trafford.
Grealish, the £100 million man who joined City from Aston Villa in 2021, was once a linchpin in Pep Guardiola’s squad, starting 21 of 23 games between January and May 2023, including both legs of the Champions League semi-final against Real Madrid and the final against Inter Milan. However, his role diminished over the past two seasons, with only 17 Premier League starts since that triumphant campaign. Reports of Guardiola questioning Grealish’s professionalism—citing late nights out and inconsistent training—culminated in his exclusion from the squad for City’s 4-0 win over Fulham and the FIFA Club World Cup. “He is able to play a really good game like in the FA Cup,” Guardiola said, referencing Grealish’s standout performances against lower-tier sides like Salford City and Plymouth Argyle, “but not the consistency to play every week with three games.” With City favoring a permanent transfer but settling for a loan, Everton offers Grealish a fresh start under David Moyes, who is eager to make him a centerpiece at Goodison Park.
Neville’s warning centers on the cultural shift Grealish faces. “My concern is that he’s going to end up going from a treble-winning Man City team, playing with Bernardo Silva, Phil Foden, Erling Haaland, and Rodri, and he’s now going to go into a team that’s got obviously inferior players around him,” Neville said. “Is he going to become disillusioned with it and feel that they’re not up to the standard of him?” This mirrors Ronaldo’s experience in 2021-22, when the Portuguese icon, returning to United after dominating at Real Madrid, grew visibly frustrated with teammates he perceived as below his level. “When Cristiano Ronaldo came back to United, it was quite clear he became frustrated playing with players that maybe wasn’t at the standard he’d been used to,” Neville added, recalling Ronaldo’s public outbursts and eventual contract termination following a controversial interview.
For Grealish, the challenge is twofold: adapting to Everton’s gritty, less glamorous style and emerging as a leader. Having captained Aston Villa, he has the pedigree to be Moyes’ go-to man alongside veteran Seamus Coleman. “I know Jack’s ambition is to get back into the England squad, so hopefully we can help him achieve that over the course of the season,” Moyes said, expressing confidence in Grealish’s ability to thrive. Unlike City’s high-pressure environment, Everton’s lack of European commitments means a lighter schedule, potentially allowing Grealish to reclaim his preferred No. 10 role rather than the left-wing position Guardiola deployed him in. Choosing the No. 18 shirt—a nod to childhood heroes Paul Gascoigne and Wayne Rooney—signals his intent to make a statement.
Yet, Neville emphasizes patience and leadership. “I think he’s going to have to show patience, I think he’s going to have to show leadership,” he said, urging Grealish to mentor younger players like Jarrad Branthwaite and inspire a squad aiming for a top-half finish. Everton’s campaign begins against newly promoted Leeds United, where Grealish is expected to debut, though his fitness remains a concern after limited pre-season training. His strict individual fitness program during the break offers hope, but regaining match sharpness will be crucial, especially with the 2026 World Cup looming. England manager Thomas Tuchel still values Grealish, but Neville warns that without becoming Everton’s “beacon of light,” he risks missing the tournament.
Grealish’s move comes at a pivotal moment for Everton, who are transitioning to their new Bramley-Moore Dock stadium and seeking stability under Moyes. The club’s new owners view Grealish as a statement signing, but his success hinges on adapting to a team that, while talented, lacks City’s firepower. His flair, once a hallmark at Villa, could electrify Goodison Park, but Neville’s cautionary tale of Ronaldo’s frustration serves as a reminder: Grealish must embrace the challenge, not resent it, to reignite his career and silence doubters.
Leave a Reply