Manchester City’s goalkeeping situation has become a focal point of intrigue as the 2025 summer transfer window nears its climax, with the club navigating a delicate balance between loyalty to their long-serving star and the allure of a world-class replacement. The Premier League champions are grappling with uncertainty surrounding their No. 1 goalkeeper, Ederson, whose future at the Etihad Stadium remains unclear amid persistent interest from Turkish giants Galatasaray. As speculation swirls, the spotlight has turned to Paris Saint-Germain’s Gianluigi Donnarumma, with reports suggesting City’s interest in the Italian sensation is tempered by a preference to retain their current squad.
Ederson, a cornerstone of City’s success since joining from Benfica in 2017, has been instrumental in their dominance, with his distribution and composure under pressure defining Pep Guardiola’s tactical blueprint. However, with the Brazilian in the final year of his contract and Galatasaray tabling a €10 million (£8.6 million) bid—deemed too low by City, who value him closer to £30 million—the door has cracked open for potential change. “Ederson didn’t come to me and say I want to leave or I have an offer,” Guardiola stated, emphasizing his desire to keep the 31-year-old. “All the players are here and are our players and I work with them… What’s going to happen, nobody knows!” His comments reflect a cautious optimism, but the club’s exploration of alternatives suggests they’re preparing for all scenarios.
Enter Gianluigi Donnarumma, the 26-year-old Italian goalkeeper whose pedigree as a Champions League winner and Euro 2020 hero makes him one of Europe’s elite. PSG’s decision to sign Lucas Chevalier from Lille for £47 million and their subsequent omission of Donnarumma from the UEFA Super Cup squad have signaled his availability. “Unfortunately, someone has decided that I can no longer be part of the group and contribute to the team’s success,” Donnarumma posted on social media, his disappointment palpable. “I am disappointed and disheartened.” With his contract nearing its end and PSG reportedly open to a £30 million (€34.6 million) deal—down from an initial £40 million—City see a potential bargain for a player approaching his peak.
The prospect of Donnarumma joining City has sparked excitement, with reports indicating the goalkeeper is keen on the move and has already held constructive talks with Guardiola. “Gigio Donnarumma has already opened doors to City move, no issues on personal terms,” one insider noted, suggesting a smooth path on the player’s side. However, City’s pursuit hinges on Ederson’s departure, as the club is reluctant to disrupt their current goalkeeping hierarchy. The recent signing of James Trafford from Burnley for £27 million adds another layer of complexity. Trafford, intended as a long-term competitor, struggled in a 2-0 loss to Tottenham, prompting renewed scrutiny of City’s goalkeeping depth. “He made a good first game and I decided to continue,” Guardiola said of Trafford’s selection, downplaying suggestions of a fixed lineup.
Despite the buzz, City have moved to clarify their stance, denying claims of an agreement on personal terms with Donnarumma. Their preference remains to retain Ederson alongside Trafford, with Stefan Ortega also in the mix, though the German is weighing his own future as a potential No. 1 elsewhere. “Manchester City want Ederson to stay at the club and remain their number one goalkeeper,” a club source affirmed, underscoring their reluctance to overhaul a position that has been a bedrock of their success. Yet, the club’s long-standing admiration for Donnarumma, coupled with his availability at a reduced fee, presents a tantalizing opportunity.
Complicating matters, City’s interest in Royal Antwerp’s Senne Lammens, a 23-year-old Belgian, has emerged as a cost-effective alternative amid stalled negotiations with PSG over Donnarumma’s price. Lammens, also a target for Manchester United, aligns with City’s strategy of investing in young, high-potential talents. However, French football expert Julien Laurens has raised concerns about Donnarumma’s fit for Guardiola’s system. “He is not a Pep type of keeper,” Laurens argued, pointing to Donnarumma’s struggles with distribution and aerial presence. “The most important thing a keeper has to do for Guardiola is being really good with the ball at his feet… Donnarumma is not good with the ball at his feet.”
As the transfer window deadline looms on September 1, 2025, City’s hierarchy, led by sporting director Hugo Viana, faces a pivotal decision. A move for Donnarumma could signal a bold new era, but it risks unsettling the squad’s balance, particularly for Trafford, who is eager for significant playing time. For now, City remain in a “wait-and-see mode,” poised to act if Ederson’s situation shifts. The coming days will determine whether the Etihad welcomes a new goalkeeping titan or doubles down on the trusted hands of their Brazilian stalwart.
Leave a Reply