In the smoky, electric haze of a packed darts arena, where the crowd’s roar feels like a pulse and every dart is a heartbeat, few names carry the mythic weight of Phil Taylor. The Power, as he’s known, is darts’ undisputed colossus—a 16-time world champion whose dominance reshaped the sport into the global juggernaut it is today. Even now, at 65, retired from the professional grind but still a towering figure in the game, Taylor’s voice commands reverence. So, when he was asked to weigh in on a hypothetical clash of titans—his prime self versus a peak Michael van Gerwen, the Dutch dynamo who inherited his throne—the darts world leaned in close. Taylor’s response was as sharp as a double-top finish: unflinching, unapologetic, and brimming with the swagger that defined his era.
The setting was a lively interview on the Club 501 podcast, where Taylor, ever the showman, didn’t miss a beat. “I’d have to say me,” he declared with a grin that could light up Alexandra Palace. “I know Michael’s brilliant, and he’s been fantastic for darts, but in my prime? I’d back myself every time.” It wasn’t arrogance, but the quiet confidence of a man who once made the oche his personal empire, rewriting record books with a flick of the wrist. For fans, it was a delicious glimpse into the mindset of a legend who, even in retirement, refuses to cede ground to the modern era’s brightest star.
Picture the matchup: a prime Phil Taylor, circa 2007, when he was a relentless machine averaging 100-plus with surgical precision, against a peak Michael van Gerwen, say 2016, when the Dutchman was a whirlwind of 180s and blistering checkouts, his green-shirted strut a terror to all comers. Both men, at their zenith, were forces of nature—Taylor with his metronomic consistency, Van Gerwen with his raw, explosive power. It’s the kind of fantasy clash that could sell out arenas twice over, a battle where every leg would feel like a heavyweight title fight. Taylor, though, has no doubts about the outcome. “In my prime, I was hitting everything,” he said, his tone laced with nostalgia but firm with conviction. “The board didn’t scare me. I’d take Michael on, and I’d fancy my chances.”
The context of this bold claim adds layers to the narrative. Taylor’s reign, spanning from the early 1990s to his retirement in 2018, was defined by an almost inhuman ability to dominate under pressure. His 14 PDC World Championships and 85 major titles are a testament to a career that set the gold standard. Van Gerwen, for his part, has carved out his own legend—three world titles, 38 majors, and a Premier League dynasty that echoed Taylor’s own. But where Taylor was the cool-headed assassin, Van Gerwen is the fiery showman, his game a volatile cocktail of aggression and flair. The contrast is tantalizing: Taylor’s icy focus versus Van Gerwen’s molten intensity. Yet, Taylor sees no contest. “Michael’s got that speed, that energy,” he acknowledged, “but I was a different beast back then. I’d wear him down.”
This isn’t the first time the darts world has debated such a dream duel. Van Gerwen himself has often tipped his hat to Taylor, calling him “the greatest ever” in past interviews, a nod to the man who paved the way for darts’ modern explosion. But the Dutchman, now 35 and battling a nagging health issue that’s dulled his edge this season, has never shied away from a challenge. His prime, marked by a 2016-17 run where he swept nearly every major in sight, was a masterclass in domination. Triple-figure averages, audacious 170 finishes, and a stage presence that could electrify a morgue—Van Gerwen at his peak was untouchable. Yet, Taylor’s belief in his own supremacy isn’t just bravado; it’s rooted in a career where he routinely dismantled the best, from Eric Bristow to Raymond van Barneveld.
The podcast hosts pressed Taylor further, probing whether Van Gerwen’s relentless pace might unsettle his rhythm. Taylor chuckled, unfazed. “He’d come at me hard, no doubt, but I’d seen it all before,” he said. “You don’t win 16 world titles by folding under pressure. I’d let him fire his shots, then pick him apart.” It’s a vivid image: Taylor, unshakable, staring down the barrel of Van Gerwen’s onslaught, calmly hitting trebles while the younger man’s intensity burns itself out. For fans, it’s a mouthwatering what-if, a clash of eras that can only live in the imagination—or perhaps a charity exhibition, if the darts gods are kind.
Beyond the bravado, Taylor’s comments carry a deeper resonance. Darts has evolved since his heyday, with bigger crowds, fatter prize pots, and a new generation led by Van Gerwen, Luke Humphries, and teen prodigy Luke Littler. Yet, Taylor’s legacy looms large, a benchmark that even Mighty Mike hasn’t surpassed. His 255 career 180s dwarf Van Gerwen’s 154, and his 11 televised nine-darters to Van Gerwen’s three are a stark reminder of his clutch brilliance. Still, Van Gerwen’s defenders would argue his era is tougher, with deeper fields and a globalized sport that demands constant travel and mental fortitude. The debate is endless, fueled by stats, nostalgia, and the passion of fans who’ve watched both men redefine what’s possible on a 2×2 board.
As the darts world buzzes with this hypothetical showdown, Taylor’s verdict adds fuel to the fire. It’s not just about who’d win, but what it represents: a clash of titans, of eras, of philosophies. Taylor, ever the strategist, sees himself outlasting the storm. “I’d love to have a crack at him, just to see,” he mused, a glint in his eye. For now, the oche remains silent, but the question lingers: could the Power’s precision still reign supreme, or would Mighty Mike’s fire burn too bright? In darts, where legends are forged one dart at a time, Taylor’s answer is clear—he’s betting on himself, and the world is listening.
Leave a Reply