In the electric afterglow of claiming his first PDC World Darts Championship crown, where the roar of Alexandra Palace still echoed in his ears and the weight of a silver trophy gleamed under the spotlights, 17-year-old Luke Littler found himself thrust into one of sport’s most enduring barroom brawls. Fresh from dismantling Michael van Gerwen 7-3 in a final that blended teenage swagger with surgical precision—averaging 102.08 and sealing the deal with a 130 checkout—Littler could have basked in the adulation, replaying his path of upsets over Raymond van Barneveld and Luke Humphries. Instead, a microphone from the BBC dangled the ultimate curveball: What’s harder, a nine-dart finish in darts or a 147 maximum break in snooker? The kid who turned heads at 16 with a world final run didn’t blink, didn’t hedge, didn’t even pause for breath. “I think it has to be a 147,” he shot back, his Warrington accent laced with that boyish certainty. “I don’t know the rules of snooker. I think you pot a red ball, you pot a coloured ball and you just go over and over again, but it’s really hard.”
Littler’s unhesitating verdict landed like a bullseye in a debate that’s pitted cue-wielding tacticians against arrow-flinging sharpshooters for decades, a cross-sport skirmish as heated as any Crucible or Ally Pally showdown. On one side, the nine-darter: darts’ diamond-studded unicorn, nine flawless throws that erase 501 points in under 30 seconds, demanding unerring accuracy across three visits to the board. It’s a feat of explosive focus, where a single wobble—a dart kissing the wire or dipping low—shatters the dream. Littler knows this terrain intimately; in 2024 alone, he notched five nine-darters, three of them televised, chasing Phil Taylor’s record of 11 with the hunger of a teen devouring late-night kebabs. His first TV perfect leg came at the Dutch Masters, a blur of 180s that left opponent Gerwyn Price shell-shocked and the crowd in rapture. “I can’t believe it, I honestly can’t believe it,” Littler marveled after one such strike, his voice a mix of disbelief and delight, as if even he couldn’t quite fathom the sorcery from his fingertips.
Yet, for all its rarity—only 96 televised nine-darters since the PDC’s dawn in 1994—the snooker maximalists counter with cold math and mounting pressure. A 147 demands 36 consecutive pots: 15 reds each followed by a black (for 120 points), then the six colors in ascending order up the table. It’s not just skill; it’s a marathon of mental endurance, where table conditions, cue ball spin, and the subtlest positional error can derail hours of buildup. Since 1982, there have been 208 official 147s, but televised ones number fewer than 100, often in frames where safety play lurks as a tempting escape hatch. Ronnie O’Sullivan, snooker’s Rocket with 15 world titles and a penchant for perfection, has compiled 15 maximums himself, including that lightning-fast 5:08 blitz at the 1997 Worlds. But even he tips the scales toward his own game. “The 147 must be harder, I think,” O’Sullivan opined in a Eurosport chat, his Essex drawl dripping with respect for darts’ daredevils. “I think what you guys do on a dartboard and the way you make it look so easy is just unbelievable, so total respect to you guys. Just being able to make a 147 or a nine-darter is a great achievement, but I tend to agree – maybe the 147 might be slightly harder, just because it’s 36 shots and you’ve got only nine to do. We have to knock out four times the amount of work that you do!”
Littler’s alignment with O’Sullivan wasn’t lost on fans, who flooded social feeds with memes blending Littler’s cheeky grin with O’Sullivan’s signature flair. The debate deepened when Michael van Gerwen, the Dutch Destroyer and three-time world champ whom Littler dethroned, weighed in on a podcast. “147. 100 per cent,” he declared without equivocation. “There are so many more factors. I think the hole-in-one is the easiest. I know people who have done a hole-in-one who have a handicap of 15 or 16 but an average darts player can’t get a nine-darter.” Van Gerwen’s point underscores the variables: darts offers a static target, no opponent interference mid-throw, and legs that reset cleanly. Snooker? It’s a chess match with balls, where a rival’s snooker can sabotage your symphony before the crescendo.
Stats analysts have crunched the numbers, revealing a tantalizing parity. Per PDC data, nine-darters strike once every 2,440 legs at the Worlds, while 147s land once per 2,041 frames at snooker’s Crucible—margins slimmer than a poorly aimed double. Adjust for viable attempts (only legs starting from 501 for darts, open frames without safeties for snooker), and the odds even out further, hovering around 2,500-to-1 for each, akin to guessing a random birthday down to the weekday. Yet, darts purists like Humphries push back, arguing the board’s unforgiving geometry—trebles the size of a postage stamp—trumps snooker’s forgiving pockets. “If you take an amateur who hasn’t played either sport and give them a set of darts, a snooker cue and a golf club, they’ll do hole-in-one first, 9 darter second and a 147 last,” Humphries quipped, only to be schooled by Mark Williams in a lighthearted challenge.
Enter Shaun Murphy, the snooker maestro and the only athlete to bag all three—hole-in-one, nine-darter, and 147—cementing his unicorn status. “The correct order is… 1. 147, 2. 9 Darter, 3. Hole in one,” he proclaimed, his verdict a mic-drop from someone who’s walked the tightrope across disciplines. Murphy’s trifecta, achieved over years of crossover curiosity, adds a layer of intrigue: Is it innate genius or sheer volume of reps? Littler, whose own crossover flirtations include golf rounds with pros, hasn’t ventured into snooker yet, but his humility shines through. Admitting ignorance of the rules—”I think you pot a red ball, you pot a coloured ball and you just go over and over again”—he still intuits the grind, perhaps drawing from his own marathon sessions honing that silky 170 checkout.
As Littler transitions from prodigy to powerhouse—eyeing the Premier League and a defense of his worlds title in 2026—his snap judgment fuels the fire without settling it. It’s a debate as timeless as the sports themselves, where darts’ sprint of perfection meets snooker’s slog of supremacy. Littler’s Worlds glory, complete with £500,000 spoils and a nation dubbing him “The Nuke,” positions him as darts’ new north star, but his nod to snooker’s 147 whispers of cross-sport kinship. In a world craving GOATs, perhaps the real winner is the rivalry itself, sparking bar bets from Birmingham to Beijing. For now, Littler grabs his ginger beer, chalks his tips, and grins: The board awaits, but the conversation? That’s just getting started.
Leave a Reply