Manchester City’s current struggles represent a significant departure from the dominance they’ve enjoyed under Pep Guardiola. After securing four consecutive Premier League titles and achieving a historic treble, the team now faces its worst run of form in nine years under Guardiola and matches the most significant losing streak since the Abu Dhabi royal family assumed ownership of the club. This isn’t a minor hiccup—it’s a full-blown crisis. The response? A decisive overhaul akin to those undertaken during previous periods of transition.
City’s history shows their willingness to act boldly when faced with adversity. In the years following the Abu Dhabi takeover, the club brought in a host of players, including stalwarts like Vincent Kompany, Pablo Zabaleta, and Carlos Tevez. Similarly, Guardiola’s arrival in 2016 triggered a spending spree of over £440 million in two summers, reshaping the squad into one of the most formidable forces in Europe. That proactive approach is what City need now. A squad that has relied on its aging core is showing its cracks, and without significant reinforcements, Guardiola’s dynasty could lose its luster.
An Aging Core and Waning Dominance
The signs of decay are evident. Of the current squad, 11 players are either over 30 or will cross that threshold by the start of next season. Injuries to key players have exposed City’s vulnerabilities, with their once-ironclad structure now faltering. The 3-1 defeat to Liverpool at Anfield marked their sixth loss in seven matches, leaving them 11 points adrift of the Premier League leaders.
With Nottingham Forest next on the calendar, City have an immediate opportunity to steady the ship. But the more pressing issue lies in planning for the long term. Guardiola must reshape his squad, not just to win games now but to lay the foundation for future triumphs. That means saying goodbye to some of the players who helped City achieve greatness but are no longer capable of sustaining their dominance.
Here’s a closer look at the key players who may need to depart as City embark on a necessary rebuild.
Kyle Walker: A Decline After a Renaissance
Kyle Walker’s resurgence during City’s treble-winning campaign was a testament to his adaptability and determination. After Guardiola doubted his ability to fit into a system that prioritized inverted full-backs, Walker fought his way back into the starting XI, even resisting a move to Bayern Munich. Yet, at 33, Walker’s performances have started to dip.
He has featured in four of City’s six recent defeats, struggling particularly in matches against Bournemouth, Tottenham, and Liverpool, where his errors contributed to costly goals. With Rico Lewis proving a capable replacement, Walker’s future in the squad looks uncertain. While his contract runs until 2026, it might be prudent for City to part ways sooner rather than later.
Jack Grealish: A Misfit in Guardiola’s System
Jack Grealish’s journey at City has been turbulent. After becoming the Premier League’s most expensive signing in 2021, he transformed from Aston Villa’s talisman into a squad player. His second season showcased his tactical evolution, with Grealish playing a crucial but understated role in City’s treble. However, injuries and inconsistent form have plagued him since.
Now in his third season, Grealish has yet to score a goal in 2024 and has seen his minutes significantly reduced following the arrival of Jeremy Doku. His lack of playing time cost him a spot in England’s Euro 2024 squad, and with the 2026 World Cup looming, a move to a club where he can play regularly could be the best option for his career. City, too, would benefit from cashing in on a player whose talents might be better suited elsewhere.
Bernardo Silva: Time to Honor His Wishes?
Bernardo Silva has been instrumental in City’s success, but his repeated desires to leave have cast a shadow over his tenure. Despite signing a new deal in 2023, his performances this season have not met his usual high standards, with just three assists to his name. Guardiola chose to retain him amid other departures last summer, but as City prepare for a rebuild, it may finally be time to let Bernardo go and invest in younger, hungrier midfield options.
Kevin De Bruyne: A Legend Facing the Inevitable
Few players have been as influential as Kevin De Bruyne, but injuries are taking their toll on the Belgian maestro. After tearing his hamstring twice in 2023, De Bruyne has struggled to regain full fitness, managing only sporadic appearances this season. With his contract set to expire in 2025, City must decide whether to continue relying on a player whose availability has become increasingly uncertain. A move to MLS or a less physically demanding league could provide De Bruyne with a fitting swan song while allowing City to refresh their midfield.
Ederson: A Changing of the Guard in Goal?
Ederson’s shot-stopping ability has been a topic of debate for years, and his recent form has done little to silence critics. Dropped for the Liverpool clash after a poor showing against Feyenoord, Ederson has seen Stefan Ortega make a compelling case for the No.1 spot. With Ortega under contract until 2026 and interest in Ederson from the Saudi Pro League, City could use this opportunity to bring in a younger goalkeeper to lead their next chapter.
Ilkay Gundogan: A Misstep on Return
Ilkay Gundogan’s brief return to City has not gone as planned. After leaving for Barcelona in 2023, financial troubles at the Catalan club paved the way for his reunion with Guardiola. However, injuries to key midfielders have forced Gundogan into an anchoring role he is ill-suited for, particularly at 34. With his contract up for renewal, it would be best for both parties to move on amicably.
Planning for the Future
City’s current predicament demands action. Guardiola and the club’s hierarchy must identify younger, dynamic players who can reinvigorate the squad. From replacing aging defenders to bolstering midfield creativity, City need to approach the next transfer window with the same ruthlessness that defined their previous rebuilds.
While this season may be a write-off in terms of silverware, the opportunity to reset and prepare for future glory is still within City’s grasp. By making tough decisions now, Guardiola can ensure that the City dynasty remains intact and ready to challenge for titles once more.