In the electrifying world of professional darts, where every dart thrown can shift fortunes and fuel fierce debates, the stage is set for one of the sport’s most compelling showdowns. As the 2025/26 PDC World Darts Championship looms on the horizon, drawing the eyes of millions to London’s Alexandra Palace, tensions are simmering between two of the game’s titans: world number two Luke Humphries and the evergreen powerhouse Michael van Gerwen. At the heart of the fray is a bold proposal to reshape the PDC’s ranking system—a change that could upend the careers of the sport’s young guns and send shockwaves through the oche.
The PDC Order of Merit, the lifeblood of professional darts rankings, has long been a two-year rolling tally of prize money, divided by 1,000 to yield points that determine seeding, invitations, and ultimately, who claims the throne as the world’s best. It’s a system that rewards consistency over flash-in-the-pan brilliance, but lately, it’s come under fire for tilting too heavily toward the marquee events. The crown jewel, the World Championship, dangles a staggering £500,000 to the victor, a sum that can catapult a player from mid-pack obscurity to the elite summit in a single fortnight. Van Gerwen, the three-time world champion from the Netherlands whose name has been synonymous with dominance since his breakout in 2014, argues this imbalance is crippling the sport’s depth.
Picture this: a grueling season of floor tournaments, European Tours, and Premier League nights, where players grind through hundreds of legs under fluorescent lights, only for one explosive holiday showdown to rewrite the entire narrative. “The World Championship now carries too much weight in deciding the sport’s top positions,” Van Gerwen declared recently, his voice carrying the weight of a man who’s seen the rankings ebb and flow over more than a decade. He’s not alone in his frustration. The Dutch maestro, currently languishing in third place with 681.25 points—dwarfed by the dueling Lukes ahead of him—has watched helplessly as the leaderboard transformed into a two-horse race. Luke Littler, the prodigious 18-year-old sensation from Warrington, recently dethroned Humphries as world number one after a masterful Grand Slam of Darts triumph, amassing 1,970.5 points to Humphries’ 1,572. That’s a chasm wide enough to swallow entire careers.
Van Gerwen’s call for reform isn’t born of sour grapes alone; it’s a plea for equity in a sport that’s exploded in popularity, thanks in no small part to the fairy-tale rise of Littler. The teenager, who burst onto the scene as a 16-year-old phenom at last year’s Ally Pally, has since claimed five televised ranking titles in 2025 alone—a feat matched only by legends Phil Taylor and Van Gerwen himself in their prime. His latest conquest? A nail-biting 16-12 victory over Humphries in the Grand Slam final, where he pocketed £150,000 and ten of the last 13 legs, averaging a blistering 100.61 with 15 maximums. “It was always going to be tough,” Littler reflected post-match, his youthful grin belying the steel in his game. “Luke played absolutely amazingly tonight.” For Humphries, the loss stung, ending his 23-month reign at the top and marking his third straight Premier final defeat. Yet, ever the warrior, he vowed retaliation: “I am going to win the Worlds. I am declaring war on him. We’re going to go to war at the World Championships, we’ll see who is the one there.”
But it’s Van Gerwen’s intervention that’s lit the fuse. Proposing a shift toward a points-based system—perhaps one that distributes rewards more evenly across the calendar—he envisions a meritocracy where sustained excellence trumps tournament lottery wins. It’s a system, he contends, that would prevent lower-ranked players from occasionally leapfrogging stars like Humphries through seeding quirks, a gripe he’s voiced before about European Tour formats. “You’d need to ask the PDC,” Van Gerwen said when pressed on the details, but his intent is clear: level the playing field to keep the fire alive for veterans like himself.
Enter Humphries, the 30-year-old Englishman whose meteoric ascent—from a shock 2023 World Championship glory to a Triple Crown haul including the Premier League and World Matchplay—has made him darts’ reluctant poster boy for the new guard. Seeded second for the upcoming Worlds, where he’ll join Littler (1), Van Gerwen (3), and a stacked field of 40 automatic qualifiers like Stephen Bunting, Gerwyn Price, and Chris Dobey, Humphries didn’t mince words in his riposte. Speaking candidly after a recent event, he suggested Van Gerwen’s advocacy reeks of self-preservation. “That’s what someone says when they’re not at the top, isn’t it?” Humphries shot back, a wry smile underscoring his confidence. “If you’re not me or Luke, of course you’d want a points system.”
The barb landed like a perfectly aimed double 16, igniting debates across darting circles. Humphries, who defended his Players Championship Finals title earlier this month amid Van Gerwen’s notable absence (the Dutchman opted for family time, marking his first miss since 2009), knows the stakes intimately. He’s clashed with Van Gerwen before—most memorably in that epic 2023 Players final, where Humphries clawed back from 9-5 down to win 11-9 despite the opponent’s nine-darter. Now, with Littler breathing down his neck and the World Championship draw set for Monday, the air crackles with anticipation. Van Gerwen, bullish as ever, dismissed notions of a prolonged “Luke era” at a recent launch event. “They’re great players, the Humphries, the Luke Littlers, things like that. But dominating for years? No. I’m still here, and I won’t allow that to happen,” he asserted, blending humor with unyielding resolve. He’s sharpening his arrows through high-stakes exhibitions against the very duo he eyes warily: “You play on a high level… against the best players in the world, against the Humphries, the Luke Littlers.”
This isn’t just locker-room banter; it’s a pivotal moment for darts. The sport, buoyed by record crowds and Littler’s social media wizardry, faces a crossroads. A points overhaul could democratize the rankings, injecting unpredictability and rewarding the tour’s unsung grinders—think Josh Rock or Damon Heta, seeded 10th and 14th, who’ve toiled for every point. Critics, however, warn it might dilute the World Championship’s mythic allure, turning Ally Pally’s cauldron into just another stop. Humphries, for one, thrives in the current setup, his 2025 haul including a World Matchplay epic where he edged Van Gerwen 18-15. “I’m really proud of what I’ve done this week,” he admitted after the Grand Slam heartbreak. “That’s three finals on the trot that I’ve lost. It’s disappointing, but I’m playing well. I said to Luke that he deserves all the success he gets.”
As December 11 approaches, with the draw promising fireworks—Littler as defending champ, Humphries hungry for revenge, and Van Gerwen lurking like a coiled spring—the PDC holds the deciding dart. Will they heed the call for change, or let the two-year merit stand as the ultimate test of mettle? One thing’s certain: in this triangle of talent, no one’s yielding ground easily. The oche awaits, and the world will watch every leg unfold.
Leave a Reply