As the spring sun dips below the Manchester skyline on March 28, 2025, a tantalizing transfer rumor is sending shockwaves through the football world. Manchester City, the perennial Premier League juggernaut, are reportedly setting their sights on a £75 million star to replace one of their most decorated stalwarts—a six-time league champion whose future at the Etihad Stadium hangs in the balance. With whispers of uncertainty swirling around their crosstown rivals Manchester United, who also covet the same prize, this potential move could ignite a seismic tug-of-war that reshapes the landscape of English football.
The target in question is Everton’s towering center-back Jarrad Branthwaite, a 22-year-old prodigy whose stock has soared after a standout 2023-24 season. Hailing from Carlisle, Branthwaite has become the heartbeat of Everton’s backline, logging 35 Premier League appearances last term and earning plaudits for his composure, physicality, and rare ability to play with both feet. His emergence has caught the eye of City’s scouts, who see him as the ideal heir to John Stones, the six-time Premier League winner whose injury-plagued campaign and contract nearing its 2026 end have fueled speculation about his departure. “He’s a specimen,” one insider remarked, nodding to Branthwaite’s blend of athleticism and technical skill—qualities that could seamlessly slot into Pep Guardiola’s intricate system.
Stones, a linchpin in City’s golden era under Guardiola, has been instrumental in their dominance, helping secure six titles since his 2016 arrival from Everton. But this season, the 30-year-old has struggled to stay fit, his absences exposing cracks in City’s defense amid a rare dip in form for the champions. With new signings like Abdukodir Khusanov and Vitor Reis joining in January, the club is clearly planning for the future, and Branthwaite’s name has risen to the top of their wish list. “We need someone who can step into that role long-term,” a voice from the City camp hinted, underscoring the urgency to find a successor who can carry the torch.
Meanwhile, across town, Manchester United’s interest adds a delicious twist to the tale. Under Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s vision to rebuild the Red Devils with a British core, Branthwaite has been a prime target since last summer, when United’s £50 million bid was rebuffed by Everton. The Toffees, bolstered by Crystal Palace’s £75 million valuation of Marc Guehi, are holding firm, demanding a similar fee for their prized asset. United’s pursuit hinges on their ability to offer Champions League football—a prospect dimmed by their mid-table struggles under new boss Rúben Amorim—but Branthwaite’s openness to the move keeps them in the race. “It’s about playing at the highest level,” he’s reportedly said, a sentiment that could tip the scales if United falter in their Europa League campaign.
For City, the stakes are just as high. Guardiola’s squad overhaul, already underway with £180 million spent in January, signals a shift as aging stars like Kevin De Bruyne and Kyle Walker near the exit. Branthwaite’s potential arrival could anchor their defense for a decade, but Everton’s resolve and United’s persistence complicate the chase. “He wants Champions League football next season,” a source close to the player noted, a demand City can almost certainly meet, unlike their rivals. Yet, Everton’s hopes of tying him to a new contract—and England boss Thomas Tuchel’s call for European experience before a regular Three Lions spot—add further layers of intrigue.
As the summer transfer window looms, this saga promises to captivate. Will City swoop in with their financial might and trophy-laden allure? Or will United, desperate to reclaim their past glory, pull off a coup? For now, Branthwaite remains Everton’s rock, but the £75 million question lingers: where will this rising star land in a battle that could define Manchester’s footballing future?
Leave a Reply