In the high-octane world of professional darts, where the sharp crack of a treble 20 can silence a roaring crowd and shift the momentum of a match in an instant, few names evoke as much awe and frustration as Michael van Gerwen. The Dutch powerhouse, once the undisputed king of the oche, has etched his legacy with a ferocity that seemed unbreakable. From his explosive 2014 World Championship triumph at age 24 to a staggering seven Premier League titles and a record 48 PDC titles, “Mighty Mike” dominated like a force of nature, amassing over £10 million in prize money and leaving rivals scrambling in his wake. His signature roar after a 180, that infectious blend of boyish glee and predatory intensity, became the soundtrack of darts’ golden era. Yet, as October 2025 unfolds, van Gerwen finds himself in uncharted territory—not at the summit, but grappling with the shadows of his former self. Enter Paul Nicholson, the sharp-tongued Australian pundit and former world champion, whose latest verdict cuts straight to the heart: for MVG to storm back to the top, he’s got to embrace a radical mindset overhaul. “Michael van Gerwen’s got to be selfish,” Nicholson asserts, his words a rallying cry wrapped in tough love.
Nicholson’s diagnosis lands amid a season that’s been equal parts triumph and torment for the 36-year-old Brabant native. Van Gerwen kicked off 2025 with a bang, defending his World Championship crown in January at London’s Alexandra Palace—a gritty 7-4 final victory over a resurgent Luke Littler that pocketed £500,000 and reaffirmed his clutch gene. The crowd erupted as he clinched the £1 million winner’s prize, his average hovering near 100 in a display that whispered of vintage MVG. “This is what I live for,” he bellowed post-match, sweat-drenched and beaming, the fire in his eyes a reminder of the man who once won three majors in a single weekend. But the highs have been fleeting. A shock quarterfinal exit at the UK Open in March, where he faltered against underdog Damon Heta, exposed cracks in his armor. The Premier League, darts’ gladiatorial weekly showdown, turned into a nightmare: van Gerwen scraped just three playoff nights across 16 weeks, finishing seventh and watching Littler and world No. 1 Luke Humphries duel for supremacy. His averages dipped below 95 in key legs, doubles eluded him like ghosts, and the mental toll was palpable—shoulder twinges forcing a mid-season break that fueled whispers of decline.
It’s a far cry from the 2017-2019 stretch when van Gerwen was a one-man monopoly, scooping 21 of 29 TV titles and rendering the Order of Merit a footnote to his reign. That era’s MVG was a juggernaut: unflappable under lights, his throw a symphony of power and precision, averaging over 105 in finals with the ease of a casual pub toss. Rivals like Gary Anderson and Peter Wright spoke in hushed tones of his “unbeatable aura,” a psychological edge honed by relentless practice and an unyielding belief. But darts, like life, is a cruel rotator—form ebbs, injuries nibble, and the influx of young guns like 18-year-old Littler has democratized the board. Van Gerwen sits third on the PDC Order of Merit with £742,250, a respectable haul but dwarfed by Humphries’ £1.8 million fortress and Littler’s meteoric £1.5 million surge. “He’s still got the talent to bury anyone on his day,” Nicholson concedes, “but the killer instinct? That’s what’s missing.”
So, what does “selfish” mean in Nicholson’s playbook? It’s not the brash arrogance of old, but a laser-focused recalibration: tuning out the noise of family life, sponsorship demands, and the relentless tour grind to prioritize the oche above all. Van Gerwen, a devoted father to his young children and a savvy businessman with Winmau endorsements, has juggled roles masterfully—but perhaps at a cost. “He’s spread too thin, helping everyone from teammates to commentators,” Nicholson argues, drawing from his own battles as a 2008 Players Championship winner who clawed back from slumps. “Michael needs to lock in, say no to distractions, and treat every practice like a final. Be selfish with his energy—it’s not greed; it’s survival.” This echoes advice from darts lore: Phil Taylor’s monastic prep routines, Raymond van Barneveld’s mental resets post-comeback. For MVG, it could mean ditching the occasional coaching gigs or family jaunts during crunch time, channeling that Dutch directness into a “me-first” regimen. “The game’s evolved,” Nicholson adds. “Littler’s got that fearless edge, Humphries that cool consistency. Mike’s got to rediscover his inner beast—the one that didn’t care about tomorrow, only the next double.”
The timing couldn’t be more urgent. October’s TV marathon—the World Grand Prix starting October 6 in Leicester—looms as van Gerwen’s redemption arena. He enters seeded third, facing a potential semifinal against Humphries, whose 2023 win there nets a £120,000 defense. A deep run could slash the rankings gap, but Nicholson’s plea resonates deeper: it’s about mentality, not just mechanics. Van Gerwen himself has hinted at introspection, admitting after a Players Championship flop in September, “I’ve got to dig deeper, find that fire again. It’s there—I feel it.” His recent World Series of Darts Finals triumph in September, a £80,000 scalp over Humphries in the semis, offered a glimmer: a 105 average, ruthless finishing, and that roar returning like an old friend. “Winning that felt like the old days,” he reflected, “but I know there’s more to unlock.”
As the season barrels toward the December Worlds, where £1 million awaits the champion, darts’ elder statesman stands at a fork. Will he heed the call to selfishness, shedding the weight of expectations to reclaim his throne? Nicholson’s not alone in his optimism; peers like Michael Bridge, co-host on the Love The Darts podcast, see parallels to van Gerwen’s 2020 resurgence post-Premier League woes. “He’s got the tools, the experience—no one’s got more majors,” Bridge notes. “A mental flip, and he’s terrifying again.” For fans, it’s a tantalizing what-if: a revitalized MVG, bellowing under Ally Pally lights, schooling the new guard. In a sport swollen to £15 million in annual prizes, buoyed by Littler’s youthquake, van Gerwen’s return wouldn’t just be a story—it’d be a seismic shift. The board’s waiting, Mike. Time to be selfish. Time to conquer.
Leave a Reply