The tennis world is abuzz with debate over whether Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner, the sport’s brightest young stars, have eclipsed the legendary duo of Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal. Nick Kyrgios, the outspoken Australian known for his sharp insights and flair on the court, recently shared his perspective on this generational question during a lively discussion on the *All on the Table* podcast with coach Patrick Mouratoglou. While acknowledging the extraordinary talent of the world No. 1 Sinner and No. 2 Alcaraz, who have dominated by winning seven of the last eight Grand Slams, Kyrgios remains hesitant to crown them above the icons of the past just yet. His nuanced take highlights the complexity of comparing eras and the enduring legacy of Federer and Nadal, while hinting at the potential for these young titans to carve out their own historic path.
Since early 2024, Alcaraz and Sinner have set the ATP Tour ablaze, splitting major titles with Sinner claiming four (including the 2025 Wimbledon) and Alcaraz securing three (notably the 2025 French Open). Their epic clashes, including back-to-back Grand Slam finals at Roland Garros and Wimbledon in 2025, have drawn comparisons to the Federer-Nadal rivalry that defined tennis from 2006 to 2008. Alcaraz leads their head-to-head 8-5, with a five-match winning streak before Sinner’s breakthrough Wimbledon victory (4-6, 6-4, 6-4, 6-4). This rivalry, marked by breathtaking shot-making and contrasting styles—Alcaraz’s explosive creativity versus Sinner’s relentless precision—has fueled speculation about whether they’ve surpassed the “Big Three” (Federer, Nadal, and Novak Djokovic). Kyrgios, however, urges caution. “It’s hard for me to say, maybe because I’m getting older too, I think they will eventually surpass them, but not right now,” he said, reflecting on the challenge of comparing today’s stars to Federer and Nadal in their prime.
Kyrgios, who famously defeated Nadal at Wimbledon 2014 and Federer in Madrid 2015, draws on his firsthand experience against the legends. He recalls Federer’s 2006 season, when the Swiss maestro won Indian Wells, Miami, and the Australian Open, wielding a slicing backhand that could disrupt Sinner’s rhythm. “The slice. I think Federer would play really well against Sinner and bring him forward, he would make him feel [uncomfortable],” Kyrgios noted, suggesting Federer’s tactical versatility could challenge the Italian’s baseline dominance. Against Alcaraz, however, Kyrgios sees a closer contest, musing, “Maybe Alcaraz beats Federer. I don’t know. It’s hard for me to say they are better right now, or maybe I don’t want to.” His reluctance stems from the Big Three’s unparalleled consistency—Federer’s 20 Grand Slams and Nadal’s 22 set a towering benchmark, with their 2006-08 battles seeing them split all majors.
The clay-court question, particularly Nadal’s dominance at Roland Garros, where he won 14 titles with a 97% win rate, is a sticking point. Kyrgios firmly believes prime Nadal remains untouchable on clay. “Nadal on the clay in his prime, I don’t think they are better,” he said, a view echoed by Mouratoglou, who added, “Nadal has such a different game on clay than anyone, so it is difficult to imagine what it would look like to play prime Rafa on clay.” Kyrgios estimates Alcaraz might beat Nadal “sometimes” but predicts Nadal would win “six or seven times out of 10” on clay, though AlcarazMiami Open champion Andy Murray agrees, cautioning against overhyping the youngsters too soon. “Alcaraz and Sinner are on the path to being two of the best, no doubt about that, but it takes time to build what Roger, Rafa, and Novak had,” Murray said, emphasizing the Big Three’s decades-long dominance.
Yet, Kyrgios sees the potential for Alcaraz and Sinner to redefine the sport. Their 2025 French Open final, a five-hour, 29-minute epic where Alcaraz saved three championship points, showcased their ability to push each other to new heights. “The things we are doing right now are great for tennis,” Alcaraz said, embracing their role in growing the sport. Sinner, reflecting on their rivalry, added, “Six grand slams are one and a half years. It’s not that big yet,” acknowledging the gap between their achievements and the Big Three’s legacy. Kyrgios, however, sees Alcaraz’s “flair and X-factor” as reminiscent of Federer and Nadal, predicting, “Alcaraz will be up there with those greats,” while praising Sinner’s consistency. As the US Open approaches, where Alcaraz defends his 2024 title, their rivalry promises more classics, with Kyrgios and fans alike watching to see if they can close the gap to tennis’s greatest icons.
Leave a Reply