The 2025 French Open has been electrified by both breathtaking tennis and a storm of controversy, with Novak Djokovic at the center of a heated debate over perceived double standards in the sport. The drama unfolded during Lorenzo Musetti’s quarter-final match against Frances Tiafoe on June 3, when the Italian, frustrated after losing a point, kicked a ball that struck a female line judge in the chest. While Musetti escaped with only a warning for unsportsmanlike conduct, the incident drew immediate comparisons to Djokovic’s disqualification from the 2020 US Open for a similar act, igniting accusations of inconsistent rule enforcement. Djokovic, however, brushed off the controversy with characteristic focus, refusing to engage in the debate as he pursues a record-extending 25th Grand Slam title at Roland Garros.
The incident occurred during a tense moment in Musetti’s match, with the world No. 7 trailing 3-5 in the second set. After dropping a ball handed to him by a ball boy, Musetti, in a rare display of frustration, volleyed it with his foot toward the backboard, inadvertently hitting the line judge. The official, standing just three meters away, was unharmed, and Musetti quickly apologized, raising his racket in a gesture of remorse. “Honestly, it was a really unlucky coincidence,” Musetti said post-match. “I was a little bit, honestly, scared, because I really didn’t want to harm nobody, of course. I immediately went to the line umpire, and I said, ‘Sorry, I apologise to everyone.’” The chair umpire, Timo Janzen, issued a code violation but allowed Musetti to continue, a decision that sparked outrage among fans and pundits who recalled Djokovic’s harsher penalty.
In 2020, Djokovic was defaulted from his fourth-round US Open match against Pablo Carreño Busta after striking a line judge in the throat with a ball hit in frustration. The incident, which required medical attention for the official, led to Djokovic’s immediate disqualification, loss of prize money, and a $267,500 fine. Fans on social media were quick to cry foul over Musetti’s leniency, with one writing, “Novak would have been dragged out of France in chains for the same thing lol. Hilarious double standards.” Another fumed, “A precedent exists: Djokovic was automatically DQed from US Open & fined. Different rules for different players… again!!!” The controversy was further fueled by comparisons to other incidents, such as Miyu Kato’s disqualification at the 2023 French Open for accidentally hitting a ball girl.
Djokovic, now 37 and chasing history in Paris, refused to be drawn into the debate. After his quarter-final victory over Alexander Zverev, he dismissed questions about Musetti’s incident, stating, “It’s really late, my focus is on my matches, what happened there doesn’t interest me at all.” His response underscored his laser-like focus on securing a fourth French Open title, which would break his tie with Margaret Court for the most career Grand Slam singles titles. Djokovic’s path to the semi-finals has been grueling, including a five-set, four-hour thriller against Musetti in the third round that ended at 3:08 a.m., the latest finish in Roland Garros history. “I don’t want to get into it,” he said of past controversies, emphasizing his desire to let his performance speak for itself.
The Musetti incident drew varied reactions from the tennis world. Frances Tiafoe, Musetti’s opponent, expressed disbelief at the lack of punishment, calling it “comical” and noting, “Obviously it’s not consistent, so it is what it is.” Former world No. 1 doubles player Rennae Stubbs, who coached Serena Williams, took to social media to argue, “Musetti is VERY LUCKY to be still on court right now. You cannot kick a ball and it hit the lines person and not be defaulted.” However, former No. 1 Jim Courier defended the umpire’s decision, pointing out the key difference: “Softness does matter. When Novak Djokovic hit the line judge in the throat, she crumbled to the ground and needed medical treatment. That’s when they’re going to default you.” Boris Becker echoed this sentiment, stating, “You can’t disqualify Musetti over something like that. The warning was justified, but you can’t compare it to Djokovic.”
Musetti, unfazed by the controversy, went on to defeat Tiafoe 6-2, 4-6, 7-5, 6-2, securing his first French Open semi-final berth. “It’s a process of growing, not just inside the court but especially off the court,” he said, reflecting on his maturity as a new father. He now faces defending champion Carlos Alcaraz, who dominated Tommy Paul 6-0, 6-1, 6-4 in the quarter-finals, for a shot at the final. Meanwhile, Djokovic prepares to face either Jannik Sinner or Alexander Bublik, with the tennis world watching closely—not just for the title, but for how the sport navigates its rules and their application. The Musetti incident has reignited discussions about consistency in tennis officiating, but for Djokovic, the focus remains clear: the pursuit of greatness on the clay of Roland Garros.
Leave a Reply