Erling Haaland, Manchester City’s prolific Norwegian striker, has redefined goal-scoring in the Premier League since his £51.2 million move from Borussia Dortmund in 2022. With a record-breaking 36 goals in his debut season and a career tally of 84 Premier League goals in 94 matches, the 24-year-old is a force of nature. Yet, as City’s FA Cup final clash against Crystal Palace on May 17, 2025, looms, a growing chorus of critics has zeroed in on Haaland’s struggles in high-stakes matches, branding him a “big-game bottler” and echoing Roy Keane’s infamous “League Two player” jab. Despite his undeniable talent, Haaland’s lackluster stats in crucial fixtures have sparked a heated debate about his true impact.
Haaland’s critics point to a glaring stat: in eight finals with Manchester City—three Community Shields, three FA Cup finals, one Champions League final, and one UEFA Super Cup—he has failed to score or assist, a record that stands at zero goals and zero assists. Posts on social media have highlighted this, with one user quipping, “007? James Bond?” in reference to his seven final appearances without a goal. His Wembley outings, including semi-finals and finals against Sheffield United, Manchester United, Arsenal, and now Crystal Palace, have been equally barren, with no goals to show for his efforts. “He tends to struggle in big matches,” one fan noted, summing up the sentiment that Haaland’s presence often fades when the spotlight burns brightest.
The criticism intensified after City’s 2024 FA Cup final loss to Manchester United, where Haaland was nullified by defenders Lisandro Martinez and Raphael Varane. Earlier that year, his anonymous performance in the Champions League quarterfinal exit to Real Madrid drew scathing reviews, with French outlet L’Equipe rating him a dismal three out of ten, claiming his display “confirmed his immense difficulties in very high-level matches.” Former Real Madrid star Rafael van der Vaart piled on, stating, “If he doesn’t score, he’s quite useless. I find him a very average player on the ball.” Keane’s “League Two” remark, made after a goalless draw against Arsenal, further fueled the narrative, pointing to Haaland’s low touch count and 14 possessions lost over two legs against Real Madrid.
Yet, Haaland’s supporters argue the criticism is overblown. His mere presence reshapes defenses, with opponents like Antonio Rudiger tasked with shadowing him, creating space for City’s world-class creators like Kevin De Bruyne and Phil Foden. In the 2022-23 season, Haaland netted 12 Champions League goals, including five in a single match against RB Leipzig and strikes in both legs against Bayern Munich, proving he can deliver in Europe’s elite competition. Against the Premier League’s “big six,” he has 12 goals in 19 games, including a hat-trick against Manchester United. “Such is Haaland’s ability in the box and physical presence, teams have to build entire game plans on stopping him,” one observer noted, emphasizing his indirect impact.
Pep Guardiola has staunchly defended his star, acknowledging Haaland’s limited minutes in some games but insisting, “When you are involved in the game, when the time comes to score a goal, you are more precise.” Despite a recent ankle injury sidelining him for weeks, Haaland’s 18 goals in the 2024-25 season, including headers against Arsenal and Crystal Palace, keep him in the Golden Boot race. However, his recent three-game slump, marked by minimal touches and missed chances, has reignited scrutiny, with some arguing City’s tiki-taka style doesn’t suit his counter-attacking strengths honed at Dortmund.
As Haaland prepares for the FA Cup final, the pressure is on to silence doubters. His career stats—49 Champions League goals in 48 matches, a record nine goals in a single U-20 World Cup match, and multiple hat-trick records—paint a picture of a generational talent. Yet, the “big-game bottler” label lingers, fueled by his finals drought. Whether he can rise to the occasion at Wembley or continue to be a lightning rod for criticism, Haaland’s journey remains one of football’s most compelling sagas.
Leave a Reply