Stefanos Tsitsipas, the Greek tennis sensation and three-time Monte Carlo Masters champion, has found himself under scrutiny following pointed remarks from an Italian tennis legend. The former world No. 1, renowned for his tactical brilliance and storied career, didn’t hold back in his assessment of Tsitsipas, declaring, “He’s not a smart player.” This critique, delivered with the bluntness of a seasoned observer, has sparked debate across the tennis world as Tsitsipas navigates a pivotal moment in his career, fresh off a strong start to the 2025 clay season.
The Italian icon’s comments come on the heels of Tsitsipas’ commanding performance at the Monte Carlo Masters, where he advanced with a straight-sets victory over Nuno Borges. At 26, Tsitsipas has already cemented himself as one of the ATP Tour’s brightest stars, with 12 career titles, including the 2019 ATP Finals and three Masters 1000 crowns in Monte Carlo. His recent win in Dubai, where he clinched his first ATP 500 title against Felix Auger-Aliassime, showcased his ability to dominate on fast courts. Yet, the Italian legend argues that Tsitsipas’ game lacks the strategic depth needed to consistently outmaneuver the sport’s elite. “He’s got all the shots, but it’s like he’s playing checkers while others are playing chess,” the icon reportedly said, suggesting that Tsitsipas relies too heavily on raw talent over calculated decision-making.
Tsitsipas’ journey has been one of highs and lows. His 2021 French Open final, where he led Novak Djokovic by two sets only to fall in a grueling five-setter, remains a defining moment. A second Grand Slam final at the 2023 Australian Open also ended in defeat to Djokovic, underscoring the fine margins at the top. Despite these setbacks, Tsitsipas has shown resilience. His 2024 Monte Carlo title, earned by defeating Jannik Sinner and Casper Ruud, marked a return to form after a challenging season marred by a shoulder injury and a coaching shake-up. Reflecting on his growth, Tsitsipas once said, “I have huge belief that I’m capable of winning not just one Grand Slam, but many of them. It’s just a matter of time.” This optimism, however, is now being tested by the Italian’s critique, which questions whether Tsitsipas can evolve beyond his current approach.
The Italian legend, whose own career was defined by cunning court craft and adaptability, pointed to specific moments in Tsitsipas’ recent matches. He highlighted instances where the Greek star appeared to force aggressive plays rather than construct points methodically. “You see him go for big shots when patience would win the rally,” the icon noted, drawing a contrast with players like Djokovic and Carlos Alcaraz, who blend power with precision. Tsitsipas’ forehand, one of the most lethal on tour, and his athleticism are undeniable strengths, but the critique suggests he sometimes overlooks opportunities to exploit opponents’ weaknesses through smarter positioning or shot selection.
This isn’t the first time Tsitsipas has faced questions about his tactical acumen. His 2021 season drew controversy over prolonged toilet breaks, with rivals like Alexander Zverev and Andy Murray accusing him of disrupting momentum. Those incidents, coupled with his split from longtime coach and father Apostolos Tsitsipas in 2024, painted a picture of a player grappling with external pressures. After the breakup, Tsitsipas admitted, “My father has been trying to train me, raise me the right way,” but chose to seek new guidance to refresh his perspective. Under coach Dimitris Chatzinikolaou, he has shown flashes of renewed focus, but the Italian’s remarks suggest there’s still work to be done.
As Tsitsipas prepares for upcoming challenges, including a clash with Lorenzo Musetti in Monte Carlo, the tennis world is watching closely. The clay courts, where he has historically thrived, offer a chance to prove his detractors wrong. His 35–55 record against top-10 players indicates he can compete with the best, but consistency remains the hurdle. The Italian legend’s critique, while harsh, may serve as a catalyst. “He’s young enough to learn, but he needs to start now,” the icon concluded, leaving the door open for redemption.
At its core, this moment is about growth. Tsitsipas, with his philosophical musings and passion for the game, has never shied away from self-reflection. Whether he can translate that into a smarter, more strategic style remains to be seen. For now, the Greek star continues his quest, undeterred by the weight of expectations or the sting of criticism, aiming to carve out a legacy that matches his undeniable potential.