In the electrified arenas of professional darts, where every throw ignites roars from the crowd and every bullseye etches history, a new rivalry is brewing that could one day eclipse the sport’s most legendary duels. As of March 19, 2025, Luke Littler and Luke Humphries, two titans of the tungsten trade, are carving out a saga that’s already drawing parallels to the greatest head-to-heads darts has ever seen. Littler, the reigning world champion at just 18, and Humphries, the world No. 1 with a trophy cabinet bursting at the seams, are threatening to rewrite the record books. Their burgeoning clash—marked by a thrilling 6-4 Humphries victory over Littler in the Night 4 Premier League final in Exeter last month—hints at a decade-defining duel. But to truly ascend to darts immortality, they’ll need to match the intensity, longevity, and drama of the top three rivalries that have shaped the game’s storied past.
First, cast your mind back to the smoky pubs and packed halls of the 1980s, where Eric Bristow and John Lowe locked horns in a feud as fierce as their aim was true. Bristow, the “Crafty Cockney,” was the game’s swaggering kingpin, clinching five BDO world titles, two of them over Lowe in 1981 and 1985. Lowe, the stoic “Old Stoneface,” wasn’t one to back down, exacting sweet revenge in the 1987 final with a display of ice-cold precision. “There was little love lost between the pair,” one observer recalled, capturing the simmering tension that fueled their battles. Over their careers, Bristow edged the head-to-head 19-12, including a 4-2 advantage in world championship clashes, their semifinal trades in 1988 and 1989 adding layers to a rivalry that was as much about pride as it was about points. For Littler and Humphries, matching this raw, personal edge—where every dart felt like a jab—would mean infusing their contests with a visceral intensity beyond their current friendly rapport.
Fast forward to the modern era, and the clash of Michael van Gerwen and Peter Wright emerges as a benchmark of relentless competition. “Mighty Mike,” with his first world title in 2014 over Wright, seemed poised to dominate like Phil Taylor before him, but “Snakebite” Wright refused to play the foil. Their rivalry peaked in the 2017 Premier League final, a nail-biter where Wright missed six match darts, letting Van Gerwen snatch an 11-10 victory that still stings fans’ memories. By the 2020 World Championship final, Wright flipped the script, dazzling with a 7-3 triumph after going 0-9 against Van Gerwen in finals. “No one could begrudge Wright his scintillating success,” a commentator noted, underlining the Scot’s dogged persistence. Today, Van Gerwen leads their head-to-head 67-25 with two draws—the most-played matchup in pro darts history. For Littler and Humphries, who’ve split their 2025 Premier League finals at one apiece, reaching this level means piling up the encounters, stacking the stakes, and trading blows in finals that leave the oche trembling.
Then there’s the seismic showdown of Phil Taylor and Raymond van Barneveld, a rivalry that bridged darts’ old guard and new dawn. Taylor, the 16-time world champion, was the sport’s untouchable colossus, but Van Barneveld, crossing from the BDO to the PDC in 2006, brought fireworks. Their 2007 world final—a 7-6 Taylor epic hailed as one of the greatest matches ever—set the tone. “Fireworks were guaranteed when Van Barneveld crossed over,” a darts historian reflected, and they delivered: Taylor’s 52-21 head-to-head lead belied the Dutchman’s knack for clutch wins, like his 2009 Premier League final upset. Their clashes weren’t just games; they were spectacles that dragged darts into the mainstream spotlight. Littler and Humphries, already household names after Humphries’ 2024 world title win over a then-16-year-old Littler, have the star power—Littler’s £500,000 world title haul this year and Humphries’ World Masters crown in February prove it. To rival Taylor and Van Barneveld, they’ll need to keep stacking blockbuster moments that transcend the board.
As Night 7 of the Premier League looms in Cardiff this week, where Littler and Humphries could lock horns again, their rivalry—still in its infancy—pulses with potential. Humphries, at 30, brings a veteran’s polish, while Littler’s youthful audacity, evidenced by his 112 average against Stephen Bunting in Exeter, promises fireworks. “It’s a friendly rivalry for now,” one fan mused, noting their post-match grins, a stark contrast to the needle of yesteryear. Yet, with Littler’s World Championship crown and Humphries’ top ranking, the stakes are climbing. To match Bristow-Lowe’s bite, Van Gerwen-Wright’s frequency, or Taylor-Van Barneveld’s grandeur, they’ll need time, tenacity, and a touch of theater. The darts world watches, breathless, as these two Lukes aim not just to compete—but to etch their names among the immortals.
Leave a Reply