As the spring of 2025 unfolds, the football world remains on edge, gripped by the ongoing saga of Manchester City’s Financial Fair Play (FFP) case—a drama that’s stretched over years and now teeters on the brink of a seismic resolution. The Premier League champions, a juggernaut under Pep Guardiola’s stewardship, face 115 charges of alleged financial rule breaches spanning from 2009 to 2018, accusations that could rewrite the club’s glittering legacy. Amid the speculation and whispers, football finance expert Kieran Maguire has stepped into the spotlight, offering a tantalizing update on the verdict’s timeline and potential fallout, based on hushed conversations with “some people high up.” His bold claim? If City are found guilty, an “80-point deduction” could be on the table, a punishment that would send shockwaves through English football.
The saga began in 2018 when the Premier League launched an investigation into City’s financial dealings, a probe that crystallized into formal charges in February 2023. The allegations are a laundry list of financial missteps: inaccurate reporting of sponsorship deals, concealed payments to managers and players, and a failure to comply with both UEFA’s regulations and the league’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR). City have staunchly denied every accusation, insisting they possess “irrefutable evidence” to clear their name. The hearing, a grueling affair that kicked off in September 2024 and wrapped up in December, has left fans, rivals, and neutrals alike in suspense, with the independent commission’s decision still shrouded in secrecy as April dawns.
Maguire, a voice of authority in football’s murky financial waters, recently shared his insights during a lively discussion. “We don’t know,” he admitted when pressed on the verdict’s release date, a confession that underscores the opacity surrounding the case. “I have spoken to some people high up, and they reckon only four or five people in the country know when the verdict will be out.” This cloak-and-dagger uncertainty has fueled endless chatter—WhatsApp groups buzzing with rumors of “this Friday” or “next Monday”—yet no one, not even Guardiola himself, seems to have a firm grasp on the timeline. The City boss had predicted a March resolution, but as that deadline slipped by, the tension only thickened.
What makes Maguire’s update so gripping is the scale of the potential punishment he envisions. Comparing City’s case to the relatively minor breaches that saw Everton and Nottingham Forest docked points—six and four, respectively, in recent seasons—he argues the stakes here are exponentially higher. “If you read the commission reports from cover to cover, they both say that these were minor breaches of the rules,” he explained. “What Manchester City are being accused of is corporate fraud over the period of nearly a decade, so, if guilty, you’ve got to add a zero onto the points deductions we’ve seen.” His estimate? A staggering 80 points, a penalty that would all but guarantee relegation for a club that’s won six of the last seven Premier League titles.
The implications are dizzying. Picture this: City, currently chasing a fifth consecutive crown in the 2024-25 season, suddenly plummeting down the table, their dynasty unraveling in real time. Maguire warns of a ripple effect that could stretch into the summer. “If it comes out in July, for example, and Man City are given a 40 or 50 point deduction, then presumably one of Leicester or Ipswich will be saying, ‘Well, if that had come out earlier, we would have avoided relegation,’” he mused. Such a scenario could spark legal battles from relegated clubs claiming financial losses, a precedent set when Burnley pursued a case against Everton over their points deduction. “There is certainly a desire from the Premier League for it to come out,” Maguire added, highlighting the league’s urgency to avoid a “hangover” clouding the next campaign.
Yet, the plot thickens with a twist: even when the verdict lands, the punishment might not follow immediately. “The big fear is that you get the verdict as to whether they are guilty or innocent of the 115 charges—but you don’t get told what the punishment is,” Maguire cautioned. “That could come later.” This staggered approach, he suggests, would “really set the cat amongst the pigeons,” leaving City’s fate—and the league’s competitive balance—in limbo. Guardiola, ever the optimist, has urged patience, but the uncertainty gnaws at a fanbase accustomed to dominance.
For now, City press on, their on-field brilliance undimmed by the off-field storm. But Maguire’s words linger like a thunderclap, hinting at a reckoning that could redefine the club’s trajectory. An 80-point deduction? It’s a number that feels both fantastical and terrifyingly plausible, given the gravity of the charges. As the football world waits, one thing is clear: when the gavel finally falls, the echoes will be felt from Manchester to the farthest reaches of the Premier League—and beyond.
Leave a Reply